The Demeanor Trap: What the Nathan Carman Case Teaches Us About Autism and True Guilt
As a person with Level 1 ASD and a long-standing interest in forensic science, I’ve always found it problematic when investigators or the media judge a person’s guilt or innocence based on how they respond emotionally at a crime scene or to terrible news. Personally, I’m far more interested in the tangible aspects of a case: how a crime scene was processed, what DNA results were found, or whether alibis could be verified. Objective, concrete data is my forte—not facial expressions, which I often struggle to read even on people I know well, let alone someone I’ve never met on a 20/20 episode, seen only through a police body camera.
With that in mind, I recently watched a 20/20 episode called “The Carman Family Murders.” I genuinely wanted to find a reason to believe Nathan Carman hadn’t killed his grandfather or mother. At first, I thought I was off to a strong start. But then, a detective stated that he found Nathan’s emotional response to his grandfather’s death “not normal.” My immediate thought: just tell anyone with autism unexpected news, and you will likely get a response you aren’t expecting—at least by neurotypical standards.
I kept watching, anticipating more bias from the investigators. While a few comments might have been avoided with better education about neurodivergence, the focus gradually shifted. Instead of fixating on Nathan’s demeanor, the show eventually presented quite a bit of circumstantial evidence, at least regarding his grandfather’s case.
The following list I had Google AI spit out because I needed some help organizing:
1. The Missing Weapon and Caliber Match
- The Purchase: On November 11, 2013—just one month before the murder—Nathan paid $2,100 cash at a gun store in Hooksett, New Hampshire, to buy a Sig Sauer 716 Patrol .308-caliber rifle.
- The Caliber Match: John Chakalos was shot three times in the head as he slept with a weapon of that exact make and .308-caliber.
- The “Lost” Gun Claim: When questioned by police about his firearm, Nathan claimed he had simply “lost” the expensive rifle and couldn’t remember where it was.
- 2. Destruction of Tech and Spoliation of Evidence
- Laptop Hard Drive: Immediately following the shooting, Nathan destroyed his laptop computer’s hard drive.
- Truck GPS Navigation:
He also removed and destroyed the GPS tracking unit inside his truck. The prosecution argued this was done deliberately to erase digital maps that would have proven his driving route on the night of the murder. - The Fishing Alibi: Civil court documents allege that the morning after his grandfather was shot, Nathan immediately went out on a boat to “go fishing,” which insurers argued was actually a trip to toss the rifle into the ocean.
3. Timeline and Opportunity
- Last Person to See Him: Nathan was the absolute last person confirmed to have seen Chakalos alive, having eaten dinner with him at his home the evening before the body was discovered.
- The Missing Hours: Chakalos was determined to have been killed around 2:00 AM. Nathan completely lacked an alibi for his exact whereabouts between midnight and 8:00 AM.
4. Financial Inheritance Tracking
- The Estate Attorney Memos: Investigators discovered a paper trail showing Nathan had sent detailed memos to his grandfather’s trusts and estates attorney prior to the murder. He explicitly demanded a breakdown of how the $42 million family fortune would be inherited, tracking exactly how the cash would bypass his mother and aunts to flow to him.
- The Bank Transfers: Prior to the shooting, Nathan had already managed to get his grandfather to transfer $550,000 into his personal bank accounts, which he completely spent within two years, providing the financial desperation that sparked the second phase of the murder scheme.
The Complete Indictment Narrative: To view the broad case layout, see the District of Vermont U.S. Attorney’s Office Official Summary.
The Full Court Filing (PDF): To read the exact legal paragraphs detailing the .308 rifle purchase and trust fund schemes, you can review the Nathan Carman Federal Indictment Document hosted by Fox News Public Records.
The evidence surrounding his grandfather’s death was largely circumstantial, so my optimism was able to persevere a bit longer. But that changed once witnesses described seeing Nathan taking a drill to the bottom of the very boat that he and his mother later took out—a trip from which only he returned alive. That detail, far more concrete than any observation about his demeanor, marked a turning point for me as a viewer.
I went into the documentary fully aware that people with ASD are statistically more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators, and that they are also overrepresented in the criminal justice system—often through no fault of their own. It’s a reality that frustrates me, as misunderstandings about neurodivergence can so easily lead to unfair suspicion or even wrongful convictions.
Unfortunately, this case turned out to be a rare and troubling example where autism simply overlapped with other, much more significant factors. Nathan Carman’s neurodivergence wasn’t what made him a suspect; it was the mounting, tangible evidence and a series of actions and choices that pointed toward guilt in two homicides. This story serves as a reminder that while we must always challenge bias and look out for systemic injustice, we also have to acknowledge when the facts themselves—rather than stereotypes or misinterpretations—are what matter most.
For a review of the full case: https://apnews.com/article/vermont-indictments-656be3e49fb222d841de98bcd3588a72
Leave a Reply